Northern New York: (Lewis County and Willsboro, NY); May 27, 2025. The farmer-driven Northern New York Agricultural Development Program (NNYADP) has published results of field trials demonstrating how farm-specific environments affect the value of forage crops as vital feed ingredients in dairy cow diets and milk production.
This proof-of-concept project has initiated a framework for developing a more efficient and cost-effective way to help dairy farms measure field crop performance to benefit milk production and farm economics. Data from the on-farm trials show the concept created by Cornell PRO-DAIRY Dairy Forage Systems Management Specialist Joe Lawrence to be viable. The complete Field Crop Performance Network project report is posted under About: Projects by Year 2024 at www.nnyagdev.org.
“This pilot project has begun the process of developing a system that will dairy farmers more efficiently utilize farm-grown forages by providing data that reflects growing environment impact on both plant performance and forage quality factors. The ultimate purpose is helping dairies understand the impact of the growing season on forage nutritional value and effectively balance their individual farms’ dairy cow diets for optimal milk production and farm sustainability,” Lawrence said.
Lawrence’s concept for a field crop performance network system suggests that collecting crop performance data from a small number of varieties of a crop at multiple locations could be as good or better and less costly in terms of time, labor, and expense than field trials of a larger number of varieties of that crop at fewer locations.
For this pilot project, field trials of two varieties each of corn, soybean, and alfalfa were established at two farms in Lewis County on the west side of New York’s six northernmost counties and in Willsboro on the east side.
Data collection included environmental measures of precipitation, growing degree days, pest and disease pressure, measures of crop performance, and economic impact predictions.
Corn silage and alfalfa silage forage samples were quality tested on a per-site basis. The Cornell Net Carbohydrate and Protein System was used to develop balanced diets for lactating cows with the forages grown at each individual location.
Analysis Evaluates Forage Impact on Dairy Diet and Costs
Evaluating the impact of the forages from each trial location on the resulting dairy cow diets and milk production offered insight into how the growing environment affects the use of and value of the crops as feed ingredients in the dairy diet. The diets were 64.6 percent and 52.8 percent forage content for the western NNY and eastern NNY field sites, respectively.
A base diet established for a 1,600-pound Holstein cow with a goal of 97 pounds of milk production with a 4.25 percent fat and 3.2 percent protein content was compared to a diet formulated using the individual farms’ forage. Analysis for predicted milk production over the base diet showed an increase with the western NNY forage-based diet and a decrease with the diet formulated on the east side.
Milk production in pounds per dry matter was 97 pounds per cow for the western NNY location compared to 88.4 pounds per cow for the eastern side.
Lower nutritional value of the forages grown at the eastern NNY location influenced a higher total feed cost with lower milk production, in contrast to the western NNY site that achieved higher milk production at a lower total feed cost.
Income Over Feed Cost (IOFC) combines feed cost and milk production into one value and is an important metric to measure farm performance. The diet modeled for the western NNY location results in an additional $1.06 in income over total feed cost compared to the eastern NNY location. Lawrence notes, “This is a substantial difference highlighting that even the same crop genetics and best practices for growing the crop, the growing environment has a significant impact on the feed value of the crop.”
This project’s analysis of multiple parameters indicated opportunities to assess plant performance in tandem with forage quality measures. For example, Lawrence says, “One measured value of fiber or fiber digestibility only explains in part how a forage will perform in the dairy cow diet; evaluating multiple measurements, as well as environmental factors such as unusually high precipitation, allow for more precise understanding of how feed may be utilized by the cow.”
Lawrence now has an initial framework for developing a new way to enhance farmers’ ability to use farm-grown forage efficiently and to better understand when forage crop value to the dairy cow diet is constrained by the farm’s growing environment and conditions or by forage management practices.
The development of this field crop performance network continues with renewed funding from the NNYADP for trials in northern New York and New York Corn and Soybean Growers Association funding to expand the trials statewide. The University of Vermont is a project adjunct collaborator.
Funding for the Northern New York Agricultural Development Program is supported by the New York State Legislature through the New York State Assembly and administrated by the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets. # # #